Sylar question
Dec. 6th, 2009 12:47 pmSince I re-watched part of season 3 last night instead of working on my presentation for class, I thought of something that's been bugging me:
Sylar couldn't have been more than about 4 when his bio-dad sold him to Martin and Virginia in 1980, because if he were older then he would have remembered living with his bio-parents. It makes sense that he repressed the memory of that one day but it wouldn't make sense for him to repress all his memories prior to that, unless he was just too young to remember much anyway. So that would put Sylar's age at about 32 in season 3.
When he confronted Martin (his adoptive dad), he said Martin had left 27 years ago. That would make Sylar about 5 when Martin left, only a year after he adopted Sylar.
Why then was Sylar's repair shop called "Gray & Son," if it would be 13 years before Sylar would be able to take over his dad's business? Who ran the business in the meantime? Martin left town; if he'd continued running his shop then it would have been pretty easy for his wife to find him. So did she take over the shop until Sylar was old enough? That doesn't seem likely, since she doesn't see his watch-repairing as anything more than a hobby.
OR did Sylar start his own shop and choose the name Gray & Son himself because he is just that messed up in the head that he wants to live the fantasy of his father still being there and approving of him?
Is it any wonder Sylar's a Woobie for a lot of fans? In addition to being the Big Bad and Draco in Leather Pants.
Sylar couldn't have been more than about 4 when his bio-dad sold him to Martin and Virginia in 1980, because if he were older then he would have remembered living with his bio-parents. It makes sense that he repressed the memory of that one day but it wouldn't make sense for him to repress all his memories prior to that, unless he was just too young to remember much anyway. So that would put Sylar's age at about 32 in season 3.
When he confronted Martin (his adoptive dad), he said Martin had left 27 years ago. That would make Sylar about 5 when Martin left, only a year after he adopted Sylar.
Why then was Sylar's repair shop called "Gray & Son," if it would be 13 years before Sylar would be able to take over his dad's business? Who ran the business in the meantime? Martin left town; if he'd continued running his shop then it would have been pretty easy for his wife to find him. So did she take over the shop until Sylar was old enough? That doesn't seem likely, since she doesn't see his watch-repairing as anything more than a hobby.
OR did Sylar start his own shop and choose the name Gray & Son himself because he is just that messed up in the head that he wants to live the fantasy of his father still being there and approving of him?
Is it any wonder Sylar's a Woobie for a lot of fans? In addition to being the Big Bad and Draco in Leather Pants.